Methionine vs Glycine - Is Too Much Muscle Meat Bad?
Muscle meat is rich in the amino acid methionine, but relatively low in glycine.
In the online health community, there has been a lot of speculation that a high intake of methionine, along with too little glycine, may promote disease by causing an imbalance in the body.
This article takes a detailed look at the science behind these ideas.
Methionine and glycine are amino acids.
They make up the structure of proteins, along with 20 other amino acids. They are found in dietary protein and also have many important functions in the body.
MethionineMethionine is an essential amino acid. This means that we need to get it from the diet in order to survive.
Luckily, methionine is easy to acquire. It is found in varying amounts in most dietary protein, especially animal protein.
It is abundant in egg whites, seafood, meat and certain nuts and seeds. Below are some examples of foods that are high in methionine ():
- Dried egg whites: 2.79 g/100 g
- Dried spirulina: 1.15 g/100 g
- Lean beef: 1.14 g/100 g
- Brazil nuts: 1.12 g/100 g
- Lean lamb: 1.09/100 g
- Bacon: 1.07 g/100 g
- Parmesan cheese: 0.96 g/100 g
- Chicken breast: 0.92 g/100 g
- Tuna: 0.88 g/100 g
Bottom Line: Methionine is an essential amino acid, abundant in eggs, seafood and meat.
GlycineSimilarly to methionine, glycine is found in varying amounts in most dietary protein.
The richest dietary source is the animal protein collagen, which is the most abundant protein in humans and many animals ().
However, collagen is usually not found in high amounts in the meat you buy at the supermarket, unless you prefer cheaper cuts.
It is found in connective tissue, tendons and ligaments, skin, cartilage and bones--stuff that is usually associated with low-quality meat.
Glycine is also found in high amounts in gelatin, a substance made from collagen. Gelatin is commonly used as a gelling agent in cooking and food production.
Dietary sources of gelatin include gelatin desserts and gummy bears. It is also an additive in various food products, such as yogurt, cream cheese, margarine and ice cream.
Below are some examples of glycine-rich foods ():
- Dry gelatin powder: 19.05 g/100 g
- Pork skin snacks: 11.92 g/100 g
- Low-fat sesame flour: 3.43 g/100 g
- Chicken skin: 3.25 g/100 g
- Dried egg whites: 2.84 g/100 g
- Bacon: 2.60 g/100 g
- Lean beef: 2.17 g/100 g
- Cuttlefish: 2.03 g/100 g
- Lean lamb: 1.75 g/100 g
However, evidence suggests that glycine synthesis from serine may not fulfill all of the body's need for glycine. That's why we may need to get a certain amount from the diet (, ).
Bottom Line: Glycine is a non-essential amino acid found in high amounts in skin, connective tissue, ligaments, tendons, cartilage and bones.
Muscle meat is relatively high in methionine, which can be turned into another amino acid called homocysteine.
Unlike methionine, homocysteine is not found in food. It is formed in the body when dietary methionine is metabolized, mainly in the liver (). Excessive consumption of methionine may lead to elevated levels of homocysteine in the blood, especially when people are deficient in certain nutrients, such as folate ().
Homocysteine is highly reactive within the body, which makes it potentially harmful in high amounts. In fact, high levels of homocysteine have been associated with several chronic diseases, such as heart disease (, ). Because of this, methionine supplements or animal protein may have adverse effects on the function of blood vessels ().
However, there is currently no strong evidence that elevated homocysteine, in itself, causes heart disease. It may simply be an indirect risk factor, statistically associated with the true cause.
A few studies have shown that reducing homocysteine levels with folate or other B-vitamins after a heart attack does not decrease the frequency of recurrent events in the heart or circulatory system (, , ). Additionally, meta-analyses found that reducing homocysteine levels had little or no effects on future heart disease events or the risk of death (, ).
Bottom Line: High amounts of methionine may lead to elevated levels of homocysteine. Homocysteine has been linked with heart disease and other chronic diseases, but whether it actually causes them is a matter of debate.
The body has a system to keep homocysteine levels within a healthy range.
This mainly involves recycling homocysteine and turning it into the amino acid cysteine or back to methionine.
When this system fails, homocysteine levels increase. Levels of methionine may also run low when homocysteine recycling is impaired.
There are three ways by which the body can reduce homocysteine levels. They are called folate-dependent remethylation, folate-independent remethylation and trans-sulphuration.
Different nutrients are required for each of these three mechanisms to work.1. Folate-dependent remethylation: This process converts homocysteine back into methionine, and helps keep base levels of homocysteine low ( ).
Three nutrients are required to keep this system running smoothly:
- Folate: This B-vitamin is probably the most important nutrient for maintaining homocysteine levels within normal limits (, , ).
- Vitamin B12: Vegetarians are often low in vitamin B12, which may cause an increase in homocysteine levels (, ).
- Riboflavin: Although riboflavin is also necessary to make this process work, riboflavin supplementation has limited effects on homocysteine levels (, ).
Several nutrients are needed for this pathway to work:
- Trimethylglycine or choline: Also called betaine, is found in many plant foods. It can also be produced from choline (, , ).
- Serine and glycine ().
The nutrients required to keep this process running include:
- Vitamin B6: When people are deficient in folate and riboflavin, low-dose vitamin B6 supplementation may effectively lower homocysteine levels (, ).
- Serine: Dietary serine may also reduce homocysteine levels after meals. Glycine has similar effects (, ).
However, nutrients are not the only factors that may affect homocysteine levels. Genetics (such as the gene), age, certain drugs, and conditions, such as liver disease and metabolic syndrome, also play a role.
Bottom Line: Under normal circumstances, the body keeps homocysteine levels within a healthy range. This requires several nutrients, such as folate, vitamin B12, vitamin B6, trimethylglycine, serine and glycine.
After eating a high-protein meal, or taking methionine supplements, circulating homocysteine increases within hours. The level of increase depends on the dose ().
However, this increase only occurs temporarily after meals, and is perfectly normal. On the other hand, an increase in the base level of homocysteine is more of a concern.
To increase base levels of homocysteine, a high dose of pure methionine is required. This dose has been estimated to be equivalent to about 5 times the normal daily intake of methionine (, , , ).
Conversely, lower doses do not increase base levels of homocysteine ().
Simply put, there is no evidence that a diet high in muscle meat increases base levels of homocysteine in healthy people.
Although homocysteine is a product of methionine metabolism, dietary methionine intake is generally not the cause of elevated base homocysteine levels.
The underlying causes of elevated homocysteine involve the body's inability to keep it within a healthy range. These include nutrient deficiencies, unhealthy lifestyle habits, diseases and genetics.
Bottom Line: A high dose of supplemental methionine may increase base levels of homocysteine. On the other hand, eating muscle meat only leads to a temporary increase in homocysteine levels that subsides soon afterwards.
Glycine may reduce homocysteine levels following high-protein meals ().
However, whether eating a lot of glycine has any effects on the base levels of homocysteine is currently unknown. More studies are needed.
On a different note, glycine supplementation may have some .
For example, it has been shown to decrease oxidative stress in elderly people, along with cysteine, and other studies suggest that glycine supplementation improves sleep quality (, ).
Bottom Line: Dietary glycine may help reduce the temporary rise in homocysteine levels after a high-protein meal. The health relevance of this is unclear.
There is no good evidence that getting too much methionine from muscle meat, or other dietary sources, causes a harmful rise in homocysteine in healthy humans.
However, this may depend on several factors. For example, some people with a mutation in the MTHFR gene may respond differently.
Although glycine appears to play an important role in reducing the temporary rise in homocysteine after a high-protein meal, its health relevance remains unclear. Several other nutrients are also important for keeping homocysteine levels under control. The most important of these are folate, vitamin B12, vitamin B6, choline and trimethylglycine.